Attraction Paradox

Attraction Paradox

Image- Generated by Joseph Street Digest using Adobe Firefly.

Part 1: The Struggle and the Offer

The lecture hall was buzzing with the sound of flipping pages and whispered fears, a stark contrast to the usual hum of mathematical discussions. Sara’s brow was furrowed in concentration, the equations on the board seeming to her more like ancient runes than anything decipherable. Why can’t I get this? she thought, her pen pausing in mid-air. Everyone else seems to be on track.

Ben glanced over, noticing the storm brewing in Sara’s expression. The light caught his pen as he scribbled a quick note, sliding it across the polished wood of the desks with a stealth only a crowded room could afford.

Note on Paper:

“Need help? 🙂 -Ben”

Sara’s eyes widened slightly as she read the note, her immediate impulse to decline softened by the genuine offer in Ben’s eyes. There was a moment of internal struggle, I can do this on my own. But what if I can’t? She looked up, meeting Ben’s gaze, and nodded subtly.

Their study group sessions began with awkward silences and cautious exchanges. Ben’s natural aptitude for math lent a comforting steadiness to their meetings. “See, when you break it down, it’s not that complicated,” Ben would suggest, his voice a mixture of encouragement and patience.

Sara found herself contributing more, her initial hesitance giving way to bursts of understanding and laughter. “I guess, when it’s explained properly, it actually makes sense,” she admitted during one session, a small smile breaking through her usual reserve.

Their conversations slowly ventured beyond the realm of mathematics, filling the spaces between problems with snippets of their lives. Through the shared struggle and mutual support, what started as a simple offer of help had morphed into an unexpected connection, bridging the gap between merely knowing someone’s name and understanding a fragment of their world. What began as study sessions soon evolved into shared coffee breaks.

Part 2: Connection and Confession

They discovered shared interests in indie bands and obscure foreign films, their similar sense of humor sparking laughter that filled the cozy corners of their favorite cafĂ©. Through the shared jokes and stories, Sara found herself not only comprehending math but enjoying it in a way she never had before, seeing patterns and solutions with a clarity that surprised her. “I never thought numbers could be this… fun,” Sara confessed one afternoon, her smile reflecting a genuine appreciation she had never felt towards math.

In the quiet of her dorm room, Sara found herself reflecting on the evolving dynamics with Ben. They were close, undeniably so, yet as she sifted through her feelings, she realized the absence of what she had expected to feel—there was no flutter of heart, no longing touch, no ache of desire. Ben was dear to her, his presence comforting, and his laughter infectious, yet the physical spark that she assumed would naturally follow their emotional closeness was conspicuously absent. This realization puzzled Sara; it contradicted what movies and stories had taught her about friendships turning into romances.

One evening, tucked into the corner of her bed with her laptop, Sara began to research, typing hesitantly into the search bar questions that had been swirling in her mind. The term ‘demisexuality’ appeared on her screen, describing someone who only feels sexual attraction after forming a strong emotional connection. The more she read, the more the pieces seemed to fit, resonating with her in a way that was both surprising and comforting. Could this be me? she pondered, feeling a mixture of relief and apprehension. The discovery offered clarity, yet also presented a myriad of questions about how to navigate her feelings and what this realization meant for her relationship with Ben.

In the solitude of her room, with the night whispering through the slightly ajar window, Sara whispered to herself, “I guess we’re all just trying to figure out where we belong, aren’t we?” The question lingered in the air, a reflection not just on her discovery but on the universal quest for connection and understanding.

The coffee shop was bustling, the cacophony of grinding beans and light chatter creating a backdrop to Sara’s tumultuous thoughts. She had chosen this public place in the hope that it would lend her some strength, a buffer against the vulnerability she was about to expose. Ben arrived, his smile wide and carefree, unaware of the storm raging in Sara’s heart.

“Ben, I have something important to tell you, and I’m not quite sure how to say it,” Sara began, her voice trembling slightly. Ben’s expression shifted, his easy smile turning into a look of concern.

“Hey, what’s wrong? You know you can tell me anything, right?” he said, reaching across the table to give her hand a reassuring squeeze.

It was that gesture, so familiar and yet suddenly so fraught with implications, that galvanized Sara. Taking a deep breath, she plunged ahead. “I’ve been doing a lot of thinking, about us, about how I feel… And I’ve come to realize that I might not feel about you the way that you think, or even the way that I thought,” Sara stumbled over the words, each one a weight.

Ben’s brow furrowed; confusion clear on his face. “I’m not sure I follow you. Are you saying you don’t like me?”

“It’s not that simple, Ben. I do like you a lot. But not in the way most people feel in a… romantic way. I recently came across this term, demisexuality, and it really resonated with me. It means I don’t feel attracted to someone unless there’s a deep emotional bond, and it’s something beyond my control,” Sara explained, searching Ben’s face for any sign of understanding.

Ben pulled back slightly, his confusion giving way to contemplation. “So, you’re saying you don’t feel that way about me? Because we’re not… emotionally close enough?”

Sara nodded, her heart aching at the bewildered hurt in Ben’s eyes. “It’s not about you not being enough. It’s about how I’m wired. I cherish our friendship, Ben, and I didn’t want to lead you on, pretending feelings that might never develop. I thought it was only fair to tell you.”

Silence fell between them, heavy and fraught with unspoken questions. Ben stared at his hands, wrestling with this new information, trying to fit it into his understanding of relationships and attraction. Sara watched him, a part of her wishing to retract everything, to avoid this discomfort, yet knowing that honesty was the only path forward if their friendship was to survive.

Part 3: Ben’s Reaction and Clashing Worldviews

Ben shook his head, a mix of disbelief and hurt tinting his voice. “This sounds… it sounds like you’re making excuses, Sara. I mean, attraction is straightforward, isn’t it? Physical, emotional, it’s all part of the human experience.” His attempt to grasp the concept was met with frustration, visible in the tightening of his jaw.

Sara, trying to maintain her composure, explained further, “It’s not about making excuses, Ben. Demisexuality is just as valid as any other orientation. It’s not that I’m not attracted to you, but my feelings don’t work in the same way, and—”

“So, you’re not attracted to me?” Ben interrupted, his tone sharpening, a mix of ego bruising and frustration clear in his words. “Because we’re not ’emotionally close’ enough? That just sounds like a complication to me.”

Their conversation escalated quickly, their clash of worldviews coming to a head. “Look, Sara, it sounds like you, and maybe others, are just seeking attention with these… terminologies. Isn’t attraction and love simpler than this?” Ben’s dismissive stance on not just demisexuality but the broader spectrum of diverse sexualities pained Sara.

Hurt yet firm, Sara defended herself, “It’s not about seeking attention, Ben. It’s about understanding who we are and how we love. Your dismissal and judgment say more about your lack of understanding than the validity of anyone’s sexual orientation.” The air between them was charged, both parties standing on opposing ends of a rift that had widened too quickly, underscored by a deep misunderstanding and inability to see eye-to-eye.

Ben, unable to reconcile his feelings or grasp Sara’s perspective, stood up abruptly, his chair scraping against the floor. “This… I can’t do this,” he muttered, more to himself than to Sara, his features a mask of unresolved emotion. Without another word, he turned and walked away, leaving a heavy silence in his wake. Sara watched him go, a mixture of sadness and resignation settling in her chest. The gap between them, both physically and ideologically, had never felt more profound.

Part 4: Resolution or Fracture?

For the remainder of the semester, Ben chose to sit far away from Sara. Sara observed as he consistently left class with a group of male friends, establishing a new routine that conspicuously excluded her. Their interactions dwindled to nothing more than awkward encounters in hallways, where Ben would walk past without so much as a glance in her direction. This pointed disregard left Sara grappling with feelings of guilt and confusion, as though her openness about her demisexuality had been a mistake, a misstep for which she was now paying dearly.

Back in her dorm room, the solitude provided too much time for self-reflection, and doubts began to crowd her thoughts. She found herself questioning the very core of her identity, wondering if perhaps Ben’s dismissal held a grain of truth. Was her understanding of love and attraction truly an unnecessary complication? These moments of self-doubt were starkly at odds with the deep-seated knowledge of her own feelings and experiences. Despite Ben’s rejection and the swirling uncertainty, Sara could not deny the validity of her feelings, the truth of her identity that transcended any argument or dismissal. Within the confines of her room, she was left to wrestle with these conflicting emotions, searching for a reconciliation between her understanding of herself and the painful rift that had opened in her personal life.

As the semester ended, Sara’s internal turmoil had reached a breaking point. She could no longer ignore the disconnect between her heart and mind, the conflict between societal expectations and her own truth. With tears in her eyes, she wrote a heartfelt letter to Ben, detailing her struggles with demisexuality and how it had affected their friendship. Despite knowing that it may not change anything, she needed to express her truth and stand up for herself.

Part 5: The Meeting

The college café buzzed with the murmur of students, but amid the noise, Sara and Ben found themselves in a bubble of apprehension and hope. Ben, looking visibly uncomfortable but earnest, broke the silence first.

“I… I owe you an apology, Sara,” Ben started, avoiding eye contact as he fiddled with his coffee cup. “For how I’ve been acting, especially after reading your letter.”

Sara was taken aback, her heart racing. “Thank you, Ben. I apologize, too. I wrote that letter in a whirlwind of emotions. I felt cornered, and somehow, writing it seemed like the only way out. In retrospect, it might not have been the best approach.”

Ben nodded, seeming to process her words. “I wanted to tell you… I would have liked to date you. But this whole thing about being demisexual and needing a deep emotional connection first, threw me off a bit. I mean, you’re not the first girl to tell me there was no ‘spark’ for them.”

Sara sighed, her gaze meeting his. “I don’t fully understand it myself, how my feelings evolve. It’s possible, if we spent more time together, that I might… develop that spark. I just don’t know.”

“And what if I want more than just hanging out?” Ben asked cautiously, his gaze intense.

Sara paused, considering. “I’m not opposed to more, but that doesn’t automatically mean I’m into you in that way. It’s complicated.”

Ben’s expression softened, a begrudging smile forming. “Everything’s more complicated than the small town I come from. But you know what? I can work with that. We can take things slow, see where it goes.”

Their conversation continued, a blend of awkwardness and optimism, as they navigated uncharted territories of understanding and connection in the chatter-filled ambiance of the college café.

This story was in part written with AI.


Subscribe now

Read The E-JSD in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

Click Here To Go To E-JSD.